Trent Reznor really wants his fans to get a high quality show out of the performance. The sound quality is always top notch and when there's a multimedia component, it's used to great effect. For example, alongside video footage with a mass surveillance theme, hidden cameras were pointed at sections of the audience and were streamed on stage. It was a delightful touch.
In the Year Zero era when other bands were cracking down on bootlegs he gave fans HD camcorders so they could capture and distribute the performances
Every time I've seen them the live experience is wonderfully theatrical and the production is incredible. I think its one of the ways he built on the legacy of his hero and influence Gary Numan, who kind of invented the light show/multimedia live performance thing in his Living Ornaments '79 tour
Wow, I feel really lucky to have been that the May 9, 2000 at Madison Square Garden, where A Perfect Circle opened. This is apparently the only time that they had Marilyn Manson come out and perform Starfuckers, Inc and The Beautiful People together.
Going through these recordings is bringing back a lot of memories!
NIN is one of the artists I didn’t expect to stand the test of time, but the quality of Reznor’s (and now Ross’s) output has just increased with time as far as I’m concerned. Very rewarding to be a fan of this band.
I think a lot of it owes to the fact that Reznor is unusually independent and started out as his own producer and engineer in addition to recording everything except the drums
The other peers in his cohort who were more collaborative largely fractured from financial and interpersonal disagreements
It's similar to the reasons a solo-founder startup has a lot of advantages for longevity despite YC being generally opposed to them
With Teeth is one of my favorites. I'd rank it higher than PHM or Broken, but yeah I only liked a few tracks on YZ or HM. I didn't really care for the EP trilogy, either. Just a few songs here and there.
The Nine Inch Noise album[0] has really been a new favorite of mine, though. The remixes frequently did stick in my head more easily, but I think it's the best album since With Teeth.
I am fine with the idea of the singer who wrote "I want to fuck you like an animal" evolving into writing Disney music and winning Oscars for it. But I am not fine with him putting the costume back on after writing Disney music and pretending he's the same person from the 90s or that he can sing those songs with even a modicum of authenticity, unless the entire NIN thing was an act. So I can't listen to the music anymore without significant disappointment.
Reznor does a very good job of not pretending to be the same guy from the 90s, his live performances are always reworking the old songs in creative ways (Closer with a gospel style backing choir for example).
I think it's honestly a good case study on how to age gracefully, it still feels he authentically inhabits his older work but obviously we shouldn't want him to continue LARPing as his mid-20s self that was writing from the brink of suicide and heroin OD
I was a huge NIN fan back in the day. I even had a DOS device driver that turned my “n” backwards like their logo. I know everything about the band that a fan from the 90s could know. The idea that Trent Reznor of the 90s would sell out and write Disney songs and then turn around and start singing his NIN songs at the same time would probably make the 90s version of him attempt suicide. At least whoever Trent Reznor was portraying to be in the 90s would have claimed that.
Like I said, if he has evolved, which all people are allowed to do, and he found God then great. But who he was in the 90s, the songs he wrote, the society he rejected and fought against versus who he is now are diametrically opposed. You can’t pick up your old songs and “evolve” them and pretend everything is okay. It’s a slap in the face to the fans who believed in his message of “Fuck this fake society”. If he left his songs in the past then I would be okay with it but to pick up his old songs and sing them nowadays makes me about as sad as I could ever be about a hero who may never have been who he claimed he was.
That’s a bit over the top, NIN today is very different to NIN back then, Trent has naturally changed as a person, so of course his long standing project has as well.
I’ve never got the impression he is pretending to be the same person as he was in the 90s
>But I am not fine with him putting the costume back on after writing Disney music and pretending he's the same person from the 90s or that he can sing those songs with even a modicum of authenticity
Have you considered that musicians do that because its what the fans demand of them? I can imagine just about every artist reaches a point where that hit song that written with meaning to them hits a level of semantic satiation from having to play that song night after night. Reznor basically wrote a song about it, but fans would likely be pissed if they went to a show and just NIN did faithful folk and bluegrass song covers all night (meaning not Industrial interpretations, which could slap, BTW).
The Downward Spiral or The Fragile sound just as good today and just as fresh. Nothing (pun intended) sounds quite like them. PHM can sound dated, but everything else holds up.
I wasn't really a fan of the song Terrible Lie, it was a bit basic and lifeless (subjectively, for me) since it was very early NIN. But the live performance of it for 'And All That Could Have Been' made it absolutely dynamic, and turned it into one of my favorite NIN songs:
NIN and Foo Fighters: both produced their first album as nearly completely solo projects, writing the music and lyrics, playing every instrument, singing, all of it. Reznor and Grohl are just astonishingly good musicians.
Pretty Hate Machine was one of the first albums completely recorded on Pro Tools v.1 but it wasn't close to being a solo project. It had four producers, including Adrian Sherwood who worked with a ton of bands including Ministry, Skinny Puppy, Pop Will Eat Itself, KMFDM, Depeche Mode...
While Trent is more industrial adjacent than industrial proper, if you ever get the chance to stop into the Industrial & Post-Punk museum in Chicago, one of the things Martin can play for you are tracks off of his original demo tape. It was cool to hear.
I'm not a fan of Foo Fighters music in general, which is an unpopular opinion in most of my social circles, but I respect Dave Grohl's talent as a musician.
There's a dude, Adam Page, from Adelaide who's been performing improvised 'solo' shows for, gee, getting on for twenty years now, using looping pedals to build songs one layer at a time into these beautiful constructions:
Foo Fighters are such a weird one because I can kind of feel why people love them, and I have mad respect for Dave Grohl's talent, but their music has always just landed in a weird zone for me. At this point I've accepted I'll usually be the lone "FF are overrated" guy in the room, but it's nice to know I'm not the only one!
Grohl was the main drummer on With Teeth as well and they both covered Gary Numan's "Down in the Park" which is a fun example of them each doing their own take on the same source material
Not the Foo Fighters drummer you were referring to, but reminds me of something I often think about.
I think Taylor Hawkins was an amazing drummer, but when Grohl said on stage that "he's the best drummer in the world" - I always wondered whether he was even the best drummer in the band!
I'll be first to acknowledge that I don't know enough to judge, but Grohl's drumming has blown me away on so many songs.
Terrible Lie is the song that created Nine Inch Nails. It was written after he got dumped by his fiancee and then he went on to write the rest of the song from Pretty Hate Machine.
Terrible Lie from "And All That Could Have Been" was a holy shit moment when I heard it. It didn't hurt that it was on a stereo that could be heard clearly from the outside of the house it was in. Just massive impact.
I attended Fragility 2.0, NIN + Soundgarden, Cold, Black & Infinite, and Peel It Back. Fragility 2.0 was probably my favorite, but they are always incredible. 20 foot tall LED screens that moved and pivoted (from overhead lighting to background screens) in 2000 was pretty mind blowing. The scrim at the opening was awesome as well. Every show has its own things, but coming in with zero expectations and getting that was such a treat.
I wish I'd seen Fragility, as that is my favorite album, but LITS was an unbelievable show as my first. We saw it in Uncasville, which apparently was one in which there were no notable technical difficulties with the infamously challenging stage setup. Definitely check it out if you haven't watched it...
Fragility 2.0 was my first NIN show. I was a junior in high school. Me, 3 friends, and my girlfriend skipped out on our symphonic band requirement to play graduation, and instead drove down to Atlanta. Our seats were certainly in the cheap section but it blew me away.
I don’t remember this exactly, but I apparently came home from that show and told my mom that if I died tomorrow, it would be OK because I’d finally seen NIN live. (Glad I didn’t, as I’ve had the chance to see them two more times so far.)
End note: that same year, someone told me that I’d grow out of liking “that kind of music”. My pre-teen daughter recently “helpfully” did the math to point out that NIN has been my favorite band for 30 years. Grow out of it, indeed.
NIN are great and especially live. Not a genre I otherwise listen to but NIN’s music I think crosses genres. I’ve seen them live a few times and it’s always a very impressive experience with a good mix of old and new. I’d recommend The Fragile and if you like electronic stuff, the accompanying remix album Things Falling Apart
I think With Teeth is a better entry point, as it's a lot more traditional musically. Bite The Hand That Feeds and Only are songs anyone can listen to.
The Fragile can be more challenging, and even though Things Falling Apart has my favorite NIN song overall (Slipping Away) the remix albums are typically challenging as well.
To be fair, nothing NIN is extremely discordant or disharmonic/arhythmic/amelodic or dread-induced like Throbbing Gristle or Nurse With Wound. NIN is always music. But the remixes are more frequently longer stretches of distortion.
I used to work with someone was really into NIN. I hadn't heard much of the music, still haven't to be honest. I just downloaded a show from that timeframe that I'll listen to later today.
I listened only to NIN during my early teens. Then I discovered Phish and years later built (and still lovingly maintain) phish.in where you can listen to all circulated concert recordings. Glad to see NIN join the party.
I'm a phish fan and my wife is a NIN fan. I went with her to several NIN shows. It's such a completely different energy and style of presentation. I'm pretty sure Trent uses a click track and the performance contain little true improvisation, but the sustained intensity is quite amazing.
Early shows were built around click tracks, often to help synchronize with lighting and video elements, but even as far back as 1999 the live band would make a point to play tracks like Starfuckers 'live' - knowing it's such a studio-heavy song, the point was to make a live version of it.
2005 saw them taking almost a garage-band approach to live playing. The Lights in the Sky tour in 2008 broke away further from synchronized video, instead using interactive LED screens (via Moment Factory), which further freed the band up to rotate their sets.
As a result, there's actually a lot of live performance and improvisation, something you can verify across the nearly 2000 recordings at ninlive.com - 2017-2024 tours in particular feature very dynamic setlists from night to night, and the Peel it Back shows famously open with Trent playing solo piano.
A lot of us don't stream NIN because we have it all in FLAC on a NAS.
Streaming platforms never appealed to me because, well, look at ninlive.com - none of that is available on Spotify. NIN fans have traditionally had a sizable techie cohort, and when iTunes Match replaced personal rips with lower quality (or entirely incorrect) versions, that turned a lot of us off too.
Hopefully streams don’t paint the actual picture. I’ve all the major albums in audio CDs (and a couple in vinyls) and listen to them without the quality loss of a streaming service. On an other note, I feel like Year Zero aged like fine wine and is still relevant.
I think that's the problem. Trent's music forces you to look at reality violently and immediately in a way that makes most people flinch and turn back to the empty emotional calories of their cotton candy pop.
NIN recently performed an amazing show at Coachella which introduced the band to the younger generation. I assume we will continue seeing an uptick in those numbers.
2018 tour was my favorite. Standing in line getting tickets was fun and loved getting to see them from the mosh pit for two nights in a row. Just saw them with my wife in Nashville about a year ago too and that show was excellent (also loved seeing all of the Gen X/millennials that are parents now bringing their kids to the show).
Yeah! They did The Perfect Drug on one of the nights and I was just blown away that he was able to do the breakdown w/o a drum machine. Also did some deep cuts like Leaving Hope off the Still EP and Last from the Broken EP. Easily in my top five all time shows.
Oh yeah. There is a drum cam video of him playing The Perfect Drug and I watch it frequently. Josh Freese is a damn good drummer, but he just lacks character for some reason.
I was there man! Wish (no pun intended) I could remember it more clearly, but them's the breaks. Maybe relistening to it will help. Also mad I lost my collection of ticket stubs cause of hasty moves through the years :( Really thankful there's resources like this though.
Oh shit, yes! Between listening to the recording & your comment more is coming back to me. IIRC I made my way down from where we were up on the lawn right when March of the Pigs kicked in, didn't go back up to meet my friends til after Down In It. One benefit of being a pretty small dude was I could almost always worm my way up to or very close to the stage barricades, got thoroughly crushed in the process & loved every second if it. Also seeing/hearing Reznor & Bowie duet on Hurt was a straight up religous experience. What a killer show! I'm guessing you were there too?
Opening for Skinny Puppy on Halloween, 1988, Irving Plaza NYC. Would have loved to be at that one! I'll have to just listen to this audio instead[1]. Very cool.
[Edit] Oh and... "The first known Nine Inch Nails recording available." Nice.
Nice to see people talking about NIN here. For me it al started with Quake and the NIN logo on the ammo, but I did not have the original soundtrack of the game.
I really discovered their music later around 1999 I think. In my memory it started by finding something in music shared by people on Napster. Soon after that I was hooked and bought their early albums. As a teenager (19) I immediately found them unique in their style. Also the music video clips they made were pieces of art. I remember that I took some clips to school to play them on a computer when we had nothing better to do and my classmates were partially disgusted by the graphics of some of the videoclips. They thought that I was a bit insane. Turns out that it ended well and made good friends till today. But not because or the videoclips ;)
Later albums have some songs that I like, but also lots of songs and albums that I don't connect with.
The connection of ex guitarist Richard Patrick and his brother Robert Patrick as T-1000 in Terminator was always a cool fact for me. Also the fact that Trent liked to play Doom and was a big fan of it made me always think that he was also just an ordinary guy like we oldskool DOS-gamers were.
Never would have thought to even look for a recording of it until now. It was the last stop on the tour and Trent called it their farewell show. Then I saw them again the following year on the NIN|JA tour.
I found a NIN concert I went to from 1995 and downloaded the entire video. I'm shocked that my memory of it was so close to what I saw recorded. That's one of the more memorable concerts because it was one where I waited overnight for tickets with a friend. My friend and I ended up 2nd in line to a rough looking character, but I asked him if he wanted a coffee from McDonald's at 6am. He politely said no, and only then did I see the swastika tattoo on his hand.
It was great. Saw them in the Bay Area. Soundgarden went on first, were as good as you would expect, then the house lights came up for the interval. After a while without the lights going down or any other indication out comes some guy in all black at the side of the stage and starts working a couple of synths, while the stage was still mostly shrouded, audience wandering about getting food and drink, chatting, general hubbub. I thought he was a roadie. Then the beat starts and, in fact, that's Trent Reznor just kicking things off without any fuss.
have you seen Pigface? NIN’s Suck came from Pigface (it’s a cover of the original, where Trent was also the vocalist, though i prefer the live version i saw with Nivek Ogre as the vocalist).
FYI: There have been rumors that Pigface, KMFDM, and Ministry will be touring North America togetherly in 2027, and that this will be the last time any of them do that.
While I don’t see it happening, given that En Esch is in the version of pigface playing next week that’d be interesting with him and Sasha on the same tour
There's a video of the 2 of them performing it live that always cracks me up. Trent is there looking like he's taking it seriously. Meanwhile Ogre is falling over himself, drugged out of his mind, trying to figure out how a cigarette work.
And yet, Ogre's part sounded much better than Trent's, because that's how it works with the 2 of them.
Fun fact: NIN made the music for the first Quake game. I used to listen to the game soundtrack with my Discman when I was a kid. Also, the nailgun weapon's ammo boxes had the NIN logo.
I actually paid money for NiN live bootleg MP3 CDs. Of course that was a long time ago. I can't remember where I bought them from. I think one of them was called reptile or something. If I remember correctly, there is at least one song on it that wasn't on any album or single.
Nope. Emo evolved from Hardcore. NIN came out of Industrial. I'm not sure if Trent dabbled in hardcore in the 80s, but as far as I'm aware, that's not where his influences were.
Every time I've seen them the live experience is wonderfully theatrical and the production is incredible. I think its one of the ways he built on the legacy of his hero and influence Gary Numan, who kind of invented the light show/multimedia live performance thing in his Living Ornaments '79 tour
Going through these recordings is bringing back a lot of memories!
https://ninlive.com/artists/nin/concerts/2000-5-9-madison-sq...
The other peers in his cohort who were more collaborative largely fractured from financial and interpersonal disagreements
It's similar to the reasons a solo-founder startup has a lot of advantages for longevity despite YC being generally opposed to them
With Teeth was fine, but I thought Year Zero and Hesitation Marks were kind of meh.
The Nine Inch Noise album[0] has really been a new favorite of mine, though. The remixes frequently did stick in my head more easily, but I think it's the best album since With Teeth.
[0]: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_lZMvLYMa4eMeBRlAA3...
I think it's honestly a good case study on how to age gracefully, it still feels he authentically inhabits his older work but obviously we shouldn't want him to continue LARPing as his mid-20s self that was writing from the brink of suicide and heroin OD
Like I said, if he has evolved, which all people are allowed to do, and he found God then great. But who he was in the 90s, the songs he wrote, the society he rejected and fought against versus who he is now are diametrically opposed. You can’t pick up your old songs and “evolve” them and pretend everything is okay. It’s a slap in the face to the fans who believed in his message of “Fuck this fake society”. If he left his songs in the past then I would be okay with it but to pick up his old songs and sing them nowadays makes me about as sad as I could ever be about a hero who may never have been who he claimed he was.
That’s a bit over the top, NIN today is very different to NIN back then, Trent has naturally changed as a person, so of course his long standing project has as well.
I’ve never got the impression he is pretending to be the same person as he was in the 90s
Have you considered that musicians do that because its what the fans demand of them? I can imagine just about every artist reaches a point where that hit song that written with meaning to them hits a level of semantic satiation from having to play that song night after night. Reznor basically wrote a song about it, but fans would likely be pissed if they went to a show and just NIN did faithful folk and bluegrass song covers all night (meaning not Industrial interpretations, which could slap, BTW).
https://youtu.be/0QbiwDD9Bt8
Which is the very appeal of live performance.
I'm not a fan of Foo Fighters music in general, which is an unpopular opinion in most of my social circles, but I respect Dave Grohl's talent as a musician.
There's a dude, Adam Page, from Adelaide who's been performing improvised 'solo' shows for, gee, getting on for twenty years now, using looping pedals to build songs one layer at a time into these beautiful constructions:
https://youtu.be/mOqbSvbTw2o
https://youtu.be/7vcZGYuFgVE
I even named one of his songs, pity it got spelt incorrectly: https://adampage.bandcamp.com/track/preventing-a-future-disa...
Long time fan here. Felt pretty groundbreaking to me way back when. Pre-cursor-ish to Angine de Poitrine... maybe.
There are dozens of us! Dozens!
Foo Fighters are such a weird one because I can kind of feel why people love them, and I have mad respect for Dave Grohl's talent, but their music has always just landed in a weird zone for me. At this point I've accepted I'll usually be the lone "FF are overrated" guy in the room, but it's nice to know I'm not the only one!
(And I've heard both Reznor and Grohl declare individually, from the stage, that they're "the best fuckin' drummer in the world")
I think Taylor Hawkins was an amazing drummer, but when Grohl said on stage that "he's the best drummer in the world" - I always wondered whether he was even the best drummer in the band!
I'll be first to acknowledge that I don't know enough to judge, but Grohl's drumming has blown me away on so many songs.
* Lights In The Sky
* Tension
* NIN + Soundgarden
* Cold, Black & Infinite
* Peel It Back
I wish I'd seen Fragility, as that is my favorite album, but LITS was an unbelievable show as my first. We saw it in Uncasville, which apparently was one in which there were no notable technical difficulties with the infamously challenging stage setup. Definitely check it out if you haven't watched it...
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL0652B79BAF05635F&si=B8Kw...
EDIT: list formatting
I don’t remember this exactly, but I apparently came home from that show and told my mom that if I died tomorrow, it would be OK because I’d finally seen NIN live. (Glad I didn’t, as I’ve had the chance to see them two more times so far.)
End note: that same year, someone told me that I’d grow out of liking “that kind of music”. My pre-teen daughter recently “helpfully” did the math to point out that NIN has been my favorite band for 30 years. Grow out of it, indeed.
It sounds like industral metal and early indie rock to me back then. I never knew it is a big shit until 20 years later.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=htofkr4Fh3Q
It's a great album, from start to finish just as you said.
This looks a like it will be a fun alternative as soon as the hug of death slows down.
edit: There's an archive! https://archive.org/details/remix-nin-com-collection
https://www.nindestruct.com/remix.html
The Fragile can be more challenging, and even though Things Falling Apart has my favorite NIN song overall (Slipping Away) the remix albums are typically challenging as well.
To be fair, nothing NIN is extremely discordant or disharmonic/arhythmic/amelodic or dread-induced like Throbbing Gristle or Nurse With Wound. NIN is always music. But the remixes are more frequently longer stretches of distortion.
2005 saw them taking almost a garage-band approach to live playing. The Lights in the Sky tour in 2008 broke away further from synchronized video, instead using interactive LED screens (via Moment Factory), which further freed the band up to rotate their sets.
As a result, there's actually a lot of live performance and improvisation, something you can verify across the nearly 2000 recordings at ninlive.com - 2017-2024 tours in particular feature very dynamic setlists from night to night, and the Peel it Back shows famously open with Trent playing solo piano.
It's been trending upwards, which is good to see, but man just a few years ago I remember it was under 3 million a month.
https://pastspot.com/artists/0X380XXQSNBYuleKzav5UO
Compare that to the top 100: https://pastspot.com/popular
Streaming platforms never appealed to me because, well, look at ninlive.com - none of that is available on Spotify. NIN fans have traditionally had a sizable techie cohort, and when iTunes Match replaced personal rips with lower quality (or entirely incorrect) versions, that turned a lot of us off too.
I was there man! Wish (no pun intended) I could remember it more clearly, but them's the breaks. Maybe relistening to it will help. Also mad I lost my collection of ticket stubs cause of hasty moves through the years :( Really thankful there's resources like this though.
[Edit] Oh and... "The first known Nine Inch Nails recording available." Nice.
[1] - https://ninlive.com/artists/nin/concerts/1988-10-31-irving-p...
I really discovered their music later around 1999 I think. In my memory it started by finding something in music shared by people on Napster. Soon after that I was hooked and bought their early albums. As a teenager (19) I immediately found them unique in their style. Also the music video clips they made were pieces of art. I remember that I took some clips to school to play them on a computer when we had nothing better to do and my classmates were partially disgusted by the graphics of some of the videoclips. They thought that I was a bit insane. Turns out that it ended well and made good friends till today. But not because or the videoclips ;)
Later albums have some songs that I like, but also lots of songs and albums that I don't connect with.
The connection of ex guitarist Richard Patrick and his brother Robert Patrick as T-1000 in Terminator was always a cool fact for me. Also the fact that Trent liked to play Doom and was a big fan of it made me always think that he was also just an ordinary guy like we oldskool DOS-gamers were.
https://ninlive.com/artists/nin/concerts/2008-12-13-planet-h...
Never would have thought to even look for a recording of it until now. It was the last stop on the tour and Trent called it their farewell show. Then I saw them again the following year on the NIN|JA tour.
https://nincatalog.com and https://merch.nincatalog.com
https://ninwiki.com
https://nintourhistory.com
https://nindestruct.com (check out the archived fan pages from the 90s)
All fan-run sites.
Those and more can be found via https://nin.fan/
Then it all kicked off.
https://v13.net/2026/10/ministry-al-jourgensen-the-hate-to-g...
And yet, Ogre's part sounded much better than Trent's, because that's how it works with the 2 of them.
They even have a product on their site (and some other Quake products): https://shop.nin.com/products/quake-nin-30th-ammo-box
And the legendary intro soundtrack: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eeNrRHty-Lo
I just wish I liked listening to his music more