17 comments

  • NetOpWibby 8 hours ago
    For people (like me) who don't know WTF Devin is: https://devin.ai
    • hobo123 7 hours ago
      the editor formerly known as Windsurf.
      • htgb 7 hours ago
        I didn't realize they both came from the same company. Apparently Windsurf was renamed Devin Desktop.

        What I associate Devin with, and what this seemingly competes with, is the cloud hosted version. The UI and harness as well as runners are hosted, and multiple people can prompt in the same session.

        • izalutski 4 hours ago
          yes, the cloud piece is the main part - it has multiple clients, web, cli, API so you can build your own. desktop coming at some point too
  • namanyayg 18 hours ago
    Open source is amazing! Any insights how you've made something so cheap and fast? Are the margins charged by Devin really this insane?
    • igorzij 18 hours ago
      thanks!!

      we've invested heavily into infra one of the non-trivial things we did there is 2 levels of isolation instead of one there are VMs with fast NVMe disks and then inside VMs lighter rootless podman sandboxes - and each organisation gets a fleet of N VMs dedicated, N>=1

      this way the VMs serve as a "soft" concurrency limit and all sessions are still isolated, guaranteed to run on your VM, and start fast

    • Atotalnoob 17 hours ago
      Devin charges a premium markup and has switched their default model to a very cheap, low quality model.

      At my organization, all of the skilled engineers use Claude Code and the bad ones use Devin cause it’s “easier”.

      It shows in the code thats written

      • dabit3 13 hours ago
        Hi, I work with the Devin team at Cognition:

        "Premium markup." If you go past the usage included in a paid plan, extra usage is billed at API pricing. In September Devin also got 30–40% cheaper in Fusion and Normal mode and 15–20% cheaper in Ultra while quality held or improved at every mode.

        "Cheap, low-quality default model." Devin isn't tied to one model. Our normal router uses Opus 5.5 at the moment (or GPT-6.2 Sol high on GPT plan), and Ultra uses Fable 5.2 (or GPT-6.2 Astra high on GPT plan), only when someone chooses the light mode specifically are they routed to SWE-2 which is actually a great model trained specifically for software engineering that benches really well and developers really love (and SWE-2 inference / usage is currently free).

        "Only the bad engineers use it." Our users include engineers from Nvidia, Exa, Modal, OpenRouter, Mercor, Ramp, and hundreds of other companies with a high bar for engineering talent, and the best ones seem to really love and appreciate the quality and shipping velocity they get with Devin.

        I encourage anyone reading this to consider asking someone they know who's used Devin within the past few months for their opinion.

      • jkelleyrtp 13 hours ago
        > Devin charges a premium markup and has switched their default model to a very cheap, low quality model.

        I work at Cognition. This is not true. The picker currently has:

        - Normal: Balances cost and intelligence with models like Opus 5.5 and GPT-6.2 Sol

        - Ultra: Highest intelligence available with Fable 5.2 and GPT-6.2 Astra

        - Lite: Fast lightweight models

        - Fusion: Multi-model harness that pairs frontier models like Opus 5.5, Fable 5.2, and GPT-6.2 Astra with a cost efficient sidekick for up to 30% cost savings

        And then you can select any of the "preview" models like SWE-2, GPT 6.2, Gemini 4 Neon, Fable 5.2, etc.

        The built-in modes are basically just "best model at xyz on cost curve" and then we have individual models people can select.

    • lawnchair 2 hours ago
      LOL this is clearly a fake comment. What a joke.
    • cadamsdotcom 10 hours ago
      Sorry but this comes off as sycophantic and thus inauthentic.

      If you invested in the company, or are affiliated somehow, consider disclosing..

      • sausagefeet 2 hours ago
        Weird that the comment is from someone who works at a GTM contracting company...
  • taudas 19 hours ago
    New product name please, your current name tells us nothing and is already taken. But I am still going to try it :)
    • iacguy 19 hours ago
      Curious which other product you're referring to? But valid will take a look on the naming conflict.

      And yes please give it a shot and let us know what you think!

      • nasso_dev 16 hours ago
        personally i think of OpenComputers, a minecraft mod
    • igorzij 18 hours ago
      thanks!! we'll seriously consider, fr
    • rl3 18 hours ago
      >... your current name tells us nothing ...

      A little harsh, but at least it's leagues ahead of Devin.

      • iacguy 11 hours ago
        fwiw - Devin is a great name and we have a lot of respect for what they’ve built!
  • nzjrs 6 hours ago
    I learnt more by visiting the Devlin Hompage and learning what it was...
  • swyx 14 hours ago
    how do you compare your approach to OpenHands (fka OpenDevin)? (https://ai.engineer/talks/iH_wV8BbS24)
    • iacguy 14 hours ago
      Big fans of OpenHands.

      The main difference from our pov is that OpenHands is an agent with its own harness. We’re unopinionated on the harness and more focused on the infrastructure it runs in. In fact we started as one of the first “persistent” sandbox providers [1]. OpenComputer runs the user’s Claude Code or Codex (you pick per thread), and you can bring your own ChatGPT/Codex subscription.

      Our focus is predominantly on building high perf specialised infra for cloud coding agents. eg: each Slack thread gets its own rootless Podman container, with state written to local disk and then persisted to a git backed store. That’s why it feels like Claude Code on your laptop: in our benchmark it opened PRs 3.3x faster than Devin, with first push in 24s vs a 62s average across the 4 most popular cloud agents [2]. It's also cheaper at at scale, we've found, than an ephemeral sandbox per session [3].

      [1] https://x.com/utpalnadiger/status/2047436177016537251 [2] https://opencomputer.dev/blog/cloud-agents-as-fast-as-local/ [3] https://opencomputer.dev/blog/opencomputer-open-source-devin...

      • swyx 1 hour ago
        ahh ok good reply. in that case the "open source Devin" is underselling it. will give this a go.
  • sleepytimetea 18 hours ago
    Don't have Slack, will it work with Discord ?
    • motatoes 18 hours ago
      hey! founder here. We have a web ui and a cli as alternatives, you can also integrate the cli with local coding agents or things like openbot. Discord can be on the roadmap! Hope you can try it and file feature request for us
      • Vaudtje 1 hour ago
        T3 code remote integration?
    • igorzij 17 hours ago
      not yet but on the roadmap!
  • Halto 7 hours ago
    what actions does agent do without any check of system and how do you control it
  • andyjtyler 18 hours ago
    is the whole thign open source? like can i spin it up in my own infra or just the harnesss code?
    • iacguy 17 hours ago
      Yes - the repo is Apache 2.0. For the harness specifically, you byo Claude Code/ Codex.

      You need one VM in your cloud plus Cloudflare Workers (the runtime of which is also open source as workerd) for Slack events.

  • SilentM68 15 hours ago
    I see the word self-hosted but don't see any mention of Ollama or dedicated home self-hosting scenario.

    What if somebody wants to just self-host on a home pc, say using Ollama to serve the models? Does OC work w/ Ollama directly, providing "its own agent capabilities" rather than relying on other agents e.g. ClaudeCode, Codex, OpenCode, etc?

    Will any of the above be supported in the future?

    • izalutski 15 hours ago
      we're planning to give at-home setups more attention at some point! for now meaning self hosting as in "in my team's cloud acct"
    • dfish 11 hours ago
      [flagged]
  • hasbot 16 hours ago
    Probably best to explain what this is directly without expecting people to know what Devin is.
    • nitroedge 13 hours ago
      Have you heard of Windsurf?
      • esperent 9 hours ago
        About a year ago I think, yes. But I've heard of at least 100 other agentic tools in that time and I don't recall what most of them do. What's windsurf?
    • NetOpWibby 8 hours ago
      Not sure why you're being downvoted, you're right. I didn't know what Devin was. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50586844
    • izalutski 15 hours ago
      this makes Devin an OpenComputer alternative!

      right? right..?

  • aman179102 10 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • hfcloud 11 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • nakaniship 9 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • ffuubarbuzz 18 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • Steelkiwer 19 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • bykhun 19 hours ago
    [dead]
  • oolteanu 15 hours ago
    [dead]