I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
I'll be here for the rest of the day. As usual, there are countless possible topics and I'll be guided by whatever you're concerned with. Please remember that I can't provide legal advice on specific cases for obvious liability reasons because I won't have access to all the facts. Please stick to a factual discussion in your questions and comments and I'll try to do the same in my answers!
Curious what the macro view of immigration looks like since all of the changes? Is there more demand for O1? are they issuing more O1? Are people paying the 100K for the H1B? Are potential immigrants less interested in immigrating to the united states? Just curious what you are seeing that normal people wouldn't.
In my practice, we've always handled a lot of O-1s but I have seen the volume go up. Fortunately, despite some concerns early on, the O-1 standard as applied by USCIS hasn't materially changed and our cases are still getting approved. Regarding the $100K payment for H-1Bs, that's not in effect now but it might be replaced by a similar fee.
Hi Peter, the N400 processing times have significantly slowed down in 2026 (particularly at San Francisco and San Jose offices). A lot of cases have been pending for 1-2 years with no response. Is there anything you can share on this topic? Any hope of kicking the processing into a higher gear? Thank you!
I know. It's just a problem and there's not much that can be done. One standard option is to ask your Congressional representative to reach out to USCIS and while the representatives are very responsive to such requests, they often don't help. But it's always worth trying. The other option is a mandamus action but I haven't seen this work in the N-400 context.
Not a question but just a comment for the readers: years ago my prospective employer (a yc company) called Peter the day before the H-1B lottery cutoff, and he got my lottery petition filed within 24 hours. I wouldn't be here without him. Thanks again, Peter!
Good morning. I am signing off now. Thank you for your great questions and comments. If I missed your question, please feel free to email me. Have a great weekend.
Am curious about the impact of AI and job market volatility on PERM applications.
If I understand correctly, PERM asks for all experience to be from a previous role. With the advent of AI over last few years, if I have worked at my current employer for a while and use AI a lot, I still cannot call it “previous experience “. This also relates to how particular skills are to be acquired and claimed when, apparently, AI does it for you often.
How do PERM applications need to evolve given current evolution in tech sector with AI?
It's still possible to rely on experience gained with the sponsoring employer if that experience is substantially different from the sponsored position.
I see you're saying NIWs are pretty rough at the moment. As a published / cited CS PhD does it make sense to wait until that clears up before pursuing positions in the US, since I'd rather not be tied to an employer
Regarding the NIW, probably waiting is the right decision but the details matter, such as how many publications, how many citations, area of expertise, etc. The O-1 nonimmigrant visa might be an option, however, because there is an O-1 structure, called the agent O-1, that is akin to self employment.
Hi Peter, I'm a Chilean citizen and maybe this question is out of scope. Is the H-1B1 visa common enough in big tech that recruiting processes take it into account, or should I be proactive in communicating that it's different from the H-1B? My worry is that it might be too niche and affect my chances of being hired. e.g "We don't have a process, it's too much work"
Also, is continually renovating the visa (5+ years) doable or there's a unwritten limit? Thanks!
I think it's important to make clear that you're Chilean and therefore eligible for the H-1B1 visa since it's not part of the H-1B lottery and is generally easy to get. Regarding a limit, there is one (although it's not an absolute one) because it's not a "dual intent" visa but this just means being well prepared to address questions related to intent when you have visa application interview.
Hey Peter, has the O1 denial or approval rate changed? The case has someone with losing their ESTA due to pictures of pot... So question any changes in approval rates for O1s with or without a misdemeanor?
In my firm, the O-1 approval rate hasn't changed - it's still very high - although the RFE rate has gone up. The change that has occurred has occurred at the Consulate level. This means that even if USCIS has approved an O-1 petition, the Consulate might still push back at the visa application stage and this pushback has become much more common. So it's critical to be well-prepared for the visa application interview since this step isn't a formality.
Not industry related, but more of a personal one - I am trying to bring my mom over Belgium - both myself and my sister are US Citizens; I know you can't provide legal advice on specific cases, so from a broader perspective, has the process for petitioning for alien relatives been impacted by, well, anything happening from a immigration standpoint in the US?
There are two steps to the process and the first step, a petition by you or your sister with USCIS, hasn't really been impacted, but the second step, her application with the U.S. Embassy in Brussels, has slowed considerably.
Honestly, I'm not familiar with that site and I don't believe it's a government website. Since appointments are now limited to one's home country with limited exceptions, the best way to schedule is to go to the specific U.S. Consulate website for that country.
Hi Peter, Thanks for the response. It is revealing as how so many immigration, and expert immigration attorneys, are unaware of the ground truth issues. Almost all countries need to use this website to book appointment in their country. The specific US consulate will ultimately redirect to this website. The problem of tripping people into doing something wrong and locking them out is so well known that there is an sub-reddit dedicated to it. https://www.reddit.com/r/usvisascheduling/
Hypothetical - a Canadian founder with a Delaware C-Corp and was denied entry on attending business meetings a few months ago. Would you recommend letting it cool off for a year before trying to fly in for business meetings again?
Hi Peter, I am an australian looking to move to USA running a succeful marketing operation in AU/U.K/USA with physical offices and employees in AU and U.K and with some customers in USA. We are not incorporated in U.S.A but how would me and my business partner (and families) plan a dual intent move to the U.S.A .. Neither of us are sure whether we want to move to U.S.A but would like to keep our options open... we have been told L-1A and E-2 are for managerial positions - is this our best bet ? Do you have experience running these ?
We represent a lot of Australian companies and founders and there are multiple options, including the E-2, E-3, L-1, and O-1. A major benefit of the E-2, E-3, and L-1 over the O-1 is that spouses can work. If you'd like to discuss your options, please email me.
So, as a Mexican who has a PhD in Computer Science [with 20 years of experience and CTO/VP experience], what options are there to get a work Visa to be able to work in the US? (I don´t care about path to citizenship)
I know that TN appears to be the most straightforward, or O-1A; but they require "sponsorship". But people have told me about EB-1A, E-2 (investing in a US startup) or O-1A.
The chicken-and-egg problem is that currently most US companies filter on the ATS question of "do you have a Visa to work here?", so it's never possible to even get a "foot" in the door to talk about options.
This is a question I already asked to LLMs, but I would be happy to read the nuances of real life; what are the options? is there a real path?
That's right, the TN and O-1 (as well as the E-2) are the most obvious options. There are options akin to self-sponsorship/employment through the O-1 and E-2, however. The EB1A is a green card path (and can be self-sponsored) and would take a while but given the strength of your background, might be worth exploring. If you'd like to discuss with me or would like a referral, please let me know.
Thanks a lot for your reply. I'd love to talk about more about it, either with you or with someone you believe could help me [for a fee I assume! :) ]; as all the info about the E A I forms make me dizzy.
Not sure how to privately contact you to follow up, so if you shoot me an email at. omar@baqueiro.com it would be lovely.
Have you seen much change in NIW adjudication? Online discussion seem to say that RFEs are much more common now even for strong cases, not sure if you're seeing the same thing.
The NIW standard as applied by USCIS is incredibly difficult to meet and the RFE and denial rate have skyrocketed. With very limited exceptions, we advise our clients not to pursue the NIW path now.
How have you seen the PERM recruitment phase change for software engineers in recent years? I’m approaching the six year H-1B limit and will have to pack my bags to head back to a country I’ve never even lived independently in. The immigration firm that my employer’s using reports it’s become extremely difficult as there’s few avenues to disqualify American candidates on the basis of the job requirements not being trainable inside six months.
Your employer's firm is right, unfortunately. While not impossible, it's become much more difficult to get PERMs approved for SWEs because of tech industry layoffs and the availability of qualified U.S. workers.
When visiting a US company that I provide services for as a self-employed person, what is the type of visa to get? I was rejected for B1/B2 visa, as I was about to attend an offsite sponsored by the company and do classic sightseeing, and people in the admin at an interview had a rejection ready before even checking a single thing I brought or ask any details.
That isn't uncommon and the only solution is to reapply but to be better prepared by consulting with an attorney beforehand. Oftentimes, B-1/B-2 applications are approved on the second or third try.
Hi Peter, appreciate all the help you have offered here over the years.
I'm a long-time Canadian TN Visa holder who has been married to an American the last three years and have not pursued a green card.
I'm thinking about applying for the marriage green card now and am wondering if you feel that any local lawyer is able to handle the process or if there are any additional considerations given the macro climate.
It's pretty straightforward so most immigration attorneys should be able to handle but because you're on a TN, you just make sure that the attorney has experience working with Canadians and handling marriage-based GC applications.
I’m curious what the biggest changes you’ve see in policy (or current interpretation of it) during the last ~year are that you feel aren’t as discussed as the more obvious/popular ones in these kinds of threads?
How are EB1B applications evaluated? Do you see more approvals/denials compared to the previous years?
I'm at an R1 university, and my NIW was rejected with them saying that Cancer research etc isn't nationally relevant, and I'm closing to maxing my duration on my H1. We just got my EB1B submitted yesterday on Premium processing, so this is extra stressful.
Unlike the NIW and EB1A, where the standards as applied by USCIS have become almost impossible to meet, USCIS is still approving EB1Bs for talented researchers. We are filing EB1Bs now more than ever. So it is a very good option to pursue.
It seems every immigrant startup founder and their early employees are applying for O1 Visas. Do you have any sense on the approval rate? What about overall volumes? And is the administration cracking down on, or giving tacit approval of this backdoor visa for our most talented immigrants?
There are a lot if different options for founders and their early employees other than the O-1 (such as the E-2). But the O-1 might be the most common and while adjudications have become tougher, the approval rate is still very high.
Thanks for doing this.
Self petitioned and approved EB1A and current priority date here.
But I am waiting for i-485 approval for past 18 months since filing. USCIS is not entertaining any outside normal processing time inquiry yet.
Do we have any options here to get USCIS to move on this. Local Congressman/senators office haven't been helpful.
Probably the only other option is to pursue a mandamus action. If you need a referral, let me know. There are several outstanding mandamus attorneys out there. They might tell you, however, that a mandamus is premature in the I-485 context.
Yes, we do and most attorneys do but of course, the work needs to fall within the attorney's pro bono policy. Send her my way. I can at least speak with her and figure what can be done.
Do you see the overall PERM process getting faster? I've heard anecdotes that PWD is taking 3 months and the PERM filing is taking < 10 months if filed now.
How does having an unconventional career path impact EB-1 or NIW applications? PhD in molecular biology, then health informatics to product management is mine. I'm uncertain if that can add up to a competent application.
Thanks for doing this. Appreciate the chance to ask the question.
As long as there's some through line among education and jobs, I don't see it as relevant. But as I've mentioned in response to other questions, right now, the EB1A and NIW standards as applied by USCIS are extremely difficult to meet.
Thank you! In my mind there's a through line. And I understand the route has gotten more difficult not less. I'm hoping to direct some independent research with that in mind, and mainly want to understand if synthesis across molecular biology/neuroscience, product management and AI is a meaningful direction to turn my efforts, if an EB1 is the goal.
Sure. Depending on a variety of factors, including country of citizenship, ownership of the startup, and investment, the E-2, H-1B, and O-1 are all options to look at.
It's essentially possible now to self-sponsor on an H-1B if you are a sole-founder (there are certain requirements) but it's even easier if you have an equal cofounder. At a minimum, the H-1B petition must be filed before you could start working for your startup.
Any advice for someone who is stuck (2nd year of H1B, no visa stamp and no consular appointment in near sight- India) on thinking about changing to O-1, so that I can geta visa stamp and travel internationally. I do work in a research role and employer is willing to sponsor O-1 as well as EB1
The O-1 is definitely worth looking at and even if you switch to an O-1, you could switch back to an H-1B at a later date without having to go through the lottery again. If you would like to discuss or would like a referral, let me know.
What is your perspective on eb2 niw for a BSc only tech worker? Small amount of publications in ML.
I hired a law firm months ago and honestly the prospects don't look very good. They have been claiming the process became much more strict and denial rates have never been higher :/
The NIW standard as currently applied by USCIS is almost impossible to meet so we have stopped doing NIWs except in extremely limited circumstances (such as for highly experienced medical researchers and basic science researchers). So, I agree with what your law firm is telling you and it's probably just not the time to pursue an NIW.
Are there risks of losing PR status (Green Card) in attempting Naturalization? Is it possible to fail in the process and be worse off for some technicality, for someone who has at worst speed-camera violations, and who may not know all the presidents' names?
Yes so that must be part of the analysis/due diligence done by an attorney in evaluating naturalization to make sure PR is not being put at risk. I've handled many cases where the decision was not to pursue naturalization.
thanks Peter! there are several reports of O1 and EB1 application approvals trending down recently. I have O1 now and the option of 1) get EB1 now, 2) move to O1A now (helpful for my work situation anyway but also dont want to ruffle feathers unnecessarily), 3) wait a year and re-evaluate.
Wondering if you think administration/attitude change is worth waiting or are my odds of success basically independent of overall trend?
In short, EB1As are almost impossible to get while O-1s are still getting approved by USCIS. The main issue with O-1s is the second step visa application at a U.S. Consulate where Consulates are questioning, pushing back on, and rejecting visa applications more than they ever have.
The US Government seems to be in attack mode when it comes to denying temporary labor visas. Will the proposed measures to ensure qualified American job candidates apply to and are considered for roles effect your business?
To clarify with an example: currently an employer can avoid attracting qualified American applicants, and still be compliant with the laws, by only publishing an advertisement in a print newspaper. Proposed changes will require the role be advertised online and an auditable record of non-immigrant applicants kept.
My question then is how such changes would affect the process of ensuring an organization can otherwise intentionally hire someone requiring a visa. What do you think, in your professional experience?
Are you referring to the November 17 proposed PERM reforms? Those concern permanent labor certification rather than temporary visas, so I'm curious how you see them affecting temporary visa sponsorship. PERM concerns permanent immigration, not temporary H-1B visas. Existing PERM requirements already extend well beyond newspaper advertisements, esp. for professional positions. The new proposal would increase documentation requirements that _already_ exist, rather than introduce something new, so why would your implied intentions, even if true, hold?
Because companies won’t want to deal with the hassle of hiring just for h1b and not getting the person permanently in the gc process, and same with applicants, if getting a gc through h1b becomes much harder they won’t even apply to the visa itself, it acts as a deterrent.
Sure they would, why not? There is tons of hassle and no guarantee the employee will even stay with you for GC but they've been hiring this way for decades bc that is the only option they have.
Getting from zero to PERM approved is around 3 (pwd/labor market is 1 year, perm is a bit over 2 now) years now at least. If the company has a layoff in between, add 2 years at least according to the new rules, and if it happens after pwd/labor market test but before term, add 3 years because those steps will need to be redone as they will be expired, which now means you have waited 1 + 2 + 1 = 4 years just to file PERM, so then another 2 years if they manage to file.
>>currently an employer can avoid attracting qualified American applicants
Why would a patriotic American employer avoid qualified applicants? Should we tighten the laws for American employers and have increased government oversight of their hiring processes?
patriotic or not, many employers like having a knob to dial in terms of selecting exactly who they want for a role. sometimes this is a choice at the hiring manager level.
Like most attorneys, I'm not a fan of the PERM process; I don't think it protects U.S. workers and just imposes financial and other burdens on employers. So, I don't think trying to fix something that is fundamentally broken makes a lot of sense and will address concerns related to the employment of U.S. workers. There has to be something better that allows U.S. employers to sponsor the workers it needs without short-selling U.S. workers.
Do you have any good resources on what someone should do if they are PR (green card holder) but detained at the border on re-entry to the US for whatever reason? Is there a way to get someone out of detention while that matter is being resolved?
Absolutely and green card holders have rights. My advice would be to establish a relationship with an attorney whom you could call if the worst happens.
The standard options to explore are the O-1, the E-2, and the L-1. The facts will dictate which option is best. If you'd like to discuss with me or would like a referral, please feel free to reach out to me.
The onboarding is largely the same but the analysis and execution have accelerated considerably so we can prepare cases a lot faster and handle a lot more work.
I read an article about ICE abducting a Canadian dentist when he arrived at a scheduled green card interview[0]. I showed it to my spouse as evidence that we should be thinking carefully about how to protect her status in this country (she’s a refuge with a green card). She thinks I’m overly paranoid and dismissed the article because she already has said green card rather than taking the intended message that ICE behaves irrationally and is a threat no matter what.
I truly know nothing of the process, being born here. Can you please share your opinion on the matter of our contrary takes (the degree of threat post-green card)? Are you aware of any cases where someone has been snatched and deported, despite having one, outside of criminal cases? Have you knowledge of cases of ICE grabbing people taking a citizenship test (she’ll be eligible soon)? How rational is my concern, in your estimation?
Thank you for conducting this AMA and sharing your time with us.
Without question, the post-green card threat is higher than it ever has been but it's still very low and the reported instances of problems rare. So, for me, the response is not for our clients to stop living their lives but to be prepare by speaking an attorney, carrying the right documents, and having a plan in place.
I think you are mentally in the right place and she is attributing to the administration too much good faith.
Facts:
(1) the Trump Admin is actively trying to claw back citizenship (which is a higher hurdle than green card) from anyone they can find a plausible legal excuse to. Usually this means a material misrepresentation (eg. A lie) on any immigration / naturalization related form or interview.
(2) the admin is speeding up immigration court proceedings, including changing dates without the normal notice (which causes well intentioned immigrants to miss a court date and be subject to deportation). Many of the detainments, arrests, and deportations ("abductions") you read about on the news are in relation to this.
(3) Anybody in the immigration process who may have missed a court date / interview, or had an arrest which was subsequently dropped / acquitted (usually during a prior administration) is becoming a target for deportation. Even green card holders who think they have "already dealt with" whatever bureaucratic issue they had are at risk. These issues can be used as an excuse to claw back a green card.
(4) Refugees are at risk. The various refugee programs that Congress passed in statute are considered illegitimate by many people in the current administration.
There's not much you can do to prevent a detainment, but you should be mentally prepared that it could happen and make some preparations[1] in case it does. Even if it never happens, this is just smart planning (like saving for retirement or writing your will).
I have some on a H1B moving to India, their H1B will be valid for the next 2 years, if they decide to comeback to the US, what would the steps be? Is it even possible?
It's very doable. You/they should speak with an immigration attorney before they return to the U.S. but if they'll be returning to the same role, then the H-1B petition approval and H-1B visa still should be valid. This assumes they'll be returning during the validity period of their H-1B.
That depends on your current status. But - assuming you don't put in jeopardy the IP of your startup - you can get a concurrent part-time H-1B or O-1 through your startup. But to be clear, you can't hold two different visa classifications at the same time.
Depending on your country of citizenship, leave and apply for an H-4 visa. The other option - if there is a truly compelling reason - is to request expedited review. But the H-4 process with USCIS is a disaster right now.
Yes, immigration for the founders and employees of startups is still working, although it's more changing. And while we've always handled a lot of E-2 visas for startups, the volume has gone up significantly.
I can't comment on European immigration but I would recommend exploring the O-1 and the H-1B. With that much experience, an O-1 might be a solid option.
regarding Europe, for Germany at least, if you have a tech job offer you can apply directly for an "EU Blue Card". It will get approved in a few months with basically no hassle. Then you can become a permanent resident within 21 months. I have done this and it was quite easy
Hi ! A citizen of Russia, PhD in math, 25+ years in tech, built 100M+ businesses. Is situation different for Russian citizens seeking EB-1 or O-1 comparing to other nationalities with similar background?
If you are outside the U.S., yes, because Russian citizens face massive delays at U.S. Consulates whether applying for a temporary visa, such as an O-1, or a permanent immigrant ("green card") visa. If you are already inside the U.S. and seeking to get a green card via EB1A or O-1 status through USCIS, then the process is really no different from the process for citizens of other countries.
I'll need to give that some thought because there are several to choose from, unfortunately. But it probably concerns those who came here illegally as children and have been law-abiding and otherwise "good citizens" the entire time but are terrified to go to work, to school, etc.
I've read that USCIS now (re)started doing unannounced neighborhood visits to check for good moral character of naturalization applicants. Do you have any recommendations regarding this? Have you seen it happen for people who have employment based greencards, or does it only apply to people who have marriage based greencards in practice? Does one have to maintain a tidy, presentable home at all times because one might get inspected at any moment? What are they even looking for?
This hasn't happened to any of our clients so it's hard for me to advise other than to just make sure to keep your green card with you and have a copy of your N-400 application handy. But my understanding is that this is exceedingly rare and has been limited primarily to those with criminal records.
Interesting that I just get downvotes without argument, though I suppose a substantial portion Hackernews demographic relies on H1b for their livelihood.
"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it."
The plain Jane fact is the US economy requires H1B workers bc we don't have enough qualified US applicants in the fields that our economy is growing in (mostly tech, but also medicine).
It's easily provable. There's one country from which the majority of immigrants are H1Bs: India. Can't use China bc there are many Chinese immigrants from long ago who didn't come as H1Bs (and who made up various Chinatowns in the US).
Indian Americans are the richest ethnicity in the US and the most likely ethnicity to be H1B holders or have arrived here through H1B work (Father's employment etc.)
If there were tons of qualified Americans who were being suppressed by H1Bs, then this demographic wouldn't be so wealthy.
At the same time, real wages for tech workers in the US have risen substantially and outpaced inflation substantially. Again if we were in a scenario where there was lots of available, qualified labor, this wouldn't happen. It especially wouldn't happen if the point of H1B hiring by tech companies was to suppress tech worker wages.
Now all those things together are puzzling: the income H1Bs earn, the rising real wages of the fields where H1Bs are employed. These don't make sense if there is a large pool of qualified applicants no company will hire.
Those data points all make sense if there isn't actually a large domestic pool of qualified talent. Then suddenly everything lines up really well. Bc H1bs are artificially limited, the talent pool would be artificially limited as well, which would drive up wages, much like we are seeing.
The H1B $100k situation seems to still be volatile. As I understand its not in effect now, but who knows what Trump might say tomorrow.
In your experience, are companies still doing H1Bs? Is it perceived as too risky to attempt now, or are people trying to rush H1Bs while the fees are "low"?
Companies are still pursuing H-1Bs because the $100K fee isn't in effect. But you are right, it could be brought back at any time so employers are concerned.
Every tech company already hires lots of Americans. There just aren't enough qualified ones for the growth these companies have.
The fiction that there are tons of qualified Americans who are boxed out of tech is persistent but doesn't make any sense when you look at how high tech salaries are and how much real wages in the field have grown in the US. It would make no sense for that to happen if the labor pool for that field was large enough to absorb all the demand
Now that the midterm elections are over, what's your outlook on the future of ICE activity?
I'm seeing a lot of news of people with legal status and no criminal records being arrested and detained (ranging from citizens, to people with pending AOS, to people who entered legally and have bona fide asylum cases) and wondering if there is likely to be any change in the near future.
There's clearly going to be more oversight but I don't think there will be any major change in ICE's activities or the activities of any DHS agency since they're still under the effective control of the Executive branch.
> According to Ms. Xie’s lawyers, because her asylum application has not yet been approved and her previous visa is expired, ICE agents were alerted when she passed through an airport security checkpoint.
Her visa was expired. She decided to break the law and remain in country. She says she has an asylum claim from her home of… China, that she has visited since coming to the US.
MAYBE relevant information other readers might want to know.
Remind me which countries allow you stay when visa expires?
An asylum applicant is considered legally in the U.S. even if their visa has expired. The merits of the claim ultimately will be decided by an asylum officer/judge but until then, the applicant has the right to be in the U.S. and the apparent merits of the claim are irrelevant and reaching conclusions about the merits based on limited information is irresponsible and unfair.
Do you do any E1 visas? they look very helpful for non resident aliens for performing incidental work during visits related to imports/exports, yet it doesn’t seem to be very popular statistically.
An E-1 visa wouldn't be a solution to what I understand you are looking to do. Schedule a call with me to discuss if you'd like because the solutions here are limited are going to be very fact-specific.
They are very fact-specific and if the applicant is from a certain country, such as Iran, the delays oftentimes reach two years. But two years is the longest I've seen. Depending on the visa type and facts, you might want to ask the appropriate Congressional representative to make an inquiry.
I know several people who applied 3.5 years ago (B-1/B-2) and have just received an invitation for a follow-up interview for upcoming weeks. Without a confirmation that the processing has concluded, though, but why would they invite otherwise.
I know a case where a person has waited for 4 years. I haven't heard of longer cases. So I'd assume 3-4 years.
Depending on the nationality, there might be some relevant local chats with more information, statistics, U.S. court cases, specialized attorneys...
H1B are importing labor that is abundant in the US, but not being used because it's cheaper to import indentured servants. Are you seeing any change in the H1B flow in the coming future?
We actually don't do a lot of H-1Bs so my view into the trends there is limited but I can tell you that the general flow of legal immigration hasn't abated and if anything has increased.
I've got a question regarding leaving an employer 180+ days after I-140 approval. Does this reliably lock in the priority date and cap-exempt extension eligibility? I'm considering either switching sponsors or taking a few years off abroad and would like to get your perspective on the biggest risks or gotchas.
Hi Peter, thanks for doing this. Is PERM effectively closed right now for mid-level SWEs? I keep hearing that 2-4 YOE recruitment fails because job postings draw lots of qualified US applicants. Would I as a mid-level SWE have better PERM odds by switching from a top-tier tech company to a less prestigious employer? For mid-level engineers on H-1B, is the realistic play to still file now, but only expect it to pass once they reach senior?
There's no question it's become harder because of layoffs, which can require an employer to end the process, and qualified applicants but such applications are still getting approved although they usually require highly specialized skills to get approved.
Hi Peter! Do you know what the situation is for marriage-based green cards? My brother has applied over a year ago, and has not heard any updates (not even an interview). He currently lives in the UK, and wants to reunite with his wife in the US. He is an Italian citizen.
Is the process frozen for everyone, or is this an exception? Is there anything he can do?
There are two ways to get a green card, in the U.S. through USCIS and abroad through the State Department (U.S. Consulate). The former process is still proceeding but the latter process effectively has been frozen while Consular officers are trained on the new public charge rules. Unfortunately, unless there's a compelling humanitarian or national interest issue, there's really nothing that can be done.
Hi Peter, thanks for doing this. Is PERM effectively closed right now for mid-level SWEs? I keep hearing that 2-4 YOE recruitment fails because job postings draw lots of qualified US applicants. Would I as a mid-level SWE have better PERM odds by switching from a top-tier tech company to a less prestigious employer? For mid-level engineers on H-1B, is the realistic play to still file now, but only expect it to pass once they reach senior?
I like that site that hunts for and exposes PERM jobs so that the companies can’t literally pretend that there are no Americans interested in these jobs.
I'm a Swiss software engineer with about 20 years in embedded and distributed systems and I'm self-petitioning for a green card, either EB2-NIW or EB1A.
If you had three months to strengthen my file, where would you spend them?
Quick rundown: I have a MS CS from the University of Hawaii and a BSC from ETH Zurich, Switzerland.
I've been in the US on E-2 since 2022 but E-2 renewal doesn't look too good.
No patents, awards or press coverage, no publications in the last 10y. No independent letter of recommendations.
Maybe a side question too, how much can I rely on Claude-as-a-lawyer and process guide? Has anyone been successful with that lately?
Claude is very good but isn't the final authority because it can miss trends and nuance but I think it's an excellent start. Right now, the EB1A and NIW standards as applied by USCIS are almost impossible to meet so my advice to you - and to nearly everyone who asks us - is to wait until there is a change in administration and the standards go back to something more reasonable, rational, and understandable.
I think he understands the startups and immigrants he helps are creating jobs (including for Americans) just fine. ~50% of billion dollar company founders are immigrants.
In principle, there could be a place for questions about immigration policy in one of these threads—although it's mostly off topic, since the intention is for people to ask about specific situations.
However, "Do you ever feel remorse for what you are doing" crosses into personal attack, and that is not allowed in this thread or any other on HN. We all have plenty to feel remorse about.
If you have a substantive point, you can make it respectfully and thoughtfully; if not, there's no need to post.
You can't attack others on HN, regardless of how wrong they are or you feel they are. We ban accounts that post like this, so please don't do it again.
Not as well as I used to because of some back pain but generally very well. I think this is because I read a book for a while before I go to sleep and don't look at my phone.
If I understand correctly, PERM asks for all experience to be from a previous role. With the advent of AI over last few years, if I have worked at my current employer for a while and use AI a lot, I still cannot call it “previous experience “. This also relates to how particular skills are to be acquired and claimed when, apparently, AI does it for you often.
How do PERM applications need to evolve given current evolution in tech sector with AI?
Also, is continually renovating the visa (5+ years) doable or there's a unwritten limit? Thanks!
As software engineers and people residing in USA, what we can do about this and how can we help to fix this, for ourselves and for others?
I know that TN appears to be the most straightforward, or O-1A; but they require "sponsorship". But people have told me about EB-1A, E-2 (investing in a US startup) or O-1A.
The chicken-and-egg problem is that currently most US companies filter on the ATS question of "do you have a Visa to work here?", so it's never possible to even get a "foot" in the door to talk about options.
This is a question I already asked to LLMs, but I would be happy to read the nuances of real life; what are the options? is there a real path?
Not sure how to privately contact you to follow up, so if you shoot me an email at. omar@baqueiro.com it would be lovely.
I'm a long-time Canadian TN Visa holder who has been married to an American the last three years and have not pursued a green card.
I'm thinking about applying for the marriage green card now and am wondering if you feel that any local lawyer is able to handle the process or if there are any additional considerations given the macro climate.
I’m curious what the biggest changes you’ve see in policy (or current interpretation of it) during the last ~year are that you feel aren’t as discussed as the more obvious/popular ones in these kinds of threads?
I'm at an R1 university, and my NIW was rejected with them saying that Cancer research etc isn't nationally relevant, and I'm closing to maxing my duration on my H1. We just got my EB1B submitted yesterday on Premium processing, so this is extra stressful.
Do you foresee that trend continuing and why?
The questions was this last time and I'll just copy it :)
"I was counted against the H1-B cap in 2017 and worked for about 3 months before I left the states.
Would I be able to use the rest of my time now if I were to get a job in the states?"
Thanks for doing this. Appreciate the chance to ask the question.
I hired a law firm months ago and honestly the prospects don't look very good. They have been claiming the process became much more strict and denial rates have never been higher :/
Wondering if you think administration/attitude change is worth waiting or are my odds of success basically independent of overall trend?
My question then is how such changes would affect the process of ensuring an organization can otherwise intentionally hire someone requiring a visa. What do you think, in your professional experience?
Your H1B visa won't last that long.
Why would a patriotic American employer avoid qualified applicants? Should we tighten the laws for American employers and have increased government oversight of their hiring processes?
Have initial requests/emails gotten easier? Has your time taken per onboarding gotten shorter?
I truly know nothing of the process, being born here. Can you please share your opinion on the matter of our contrary takes (the degree of threat post-green card)? Are you aware of any cases where someone has been snatched and deported, despite having one, outside of criminal cases? Have you knowledge of cases of ICE grabbing people taking a citizenship test (she’ll be eligible soon)? How rational is my concern, in your estimation?
Thank you for conducting this AMA and sharing your time with us.
0. https://www.techdirt.com/2026/11/17/pissed-off-judge-orders-...
I think you are mentally in the right place and she is attributing to the administration too much good faith.
Facts:
(1) the Trump Admin is actively trying to claw back citizenship (which is a higher hurdle than green card) from anyone they can find a plausible legal excuse to. Usually this means a material misrepresentation (eg. A lie) on any immigration / naturalization related form or interview.
(2) the admin is speeding up immigration court proceedings, including changing dates without the normal notice (which causes well intentioned immigrants to miss a court date and be subject to deportation). Many of the detainments, arrests, and deportations ("abductions") you read about on the news are in relation to this.
(3) Anybody in the immigration process who may have missed a court date / interview, or had an arrest which was subsequently dropped / acquitted (usually during a prior administration) is becoming a target for deportation. Even green card holders who think they have "already dealt with" whatever bureaucratic issue they had are at risk. These issues can be used as an excuse to claw back a green card.
(4) Refugees are at risk. The various refugee programs that Congress passed in statute are considered illegitimate by many people in the current administration.
There's not much you can do to prevent a detainment, but you should be mentally prepared that it could happen and make some preparations[1] in case it does. Even if it never happens, this is just smart planning (like saving for retirement or writing your will).
[1] https://www.immigrantdefenseproject.org/wp-content/uploads/E...
This guy is trying to terrify his wife for no reason other than a political win, I feel bad for her.
No one knows what the future holds and what new shenanigans may happen
What are my realistic options for starting a company without giving up my current job?
I’ll need to figure out potential IP issues, seems sticky because I have a bunch of patents at $dayjob.
I guess that limits me to something completely unrelated?
"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it."
It's easily provable. There's one country from which the majority of immigrants are H1Bs: India. Can't use China bc there are many Chinese immigrants from long ago who didn't come as H1Bs (and who made up various Chinatowns in the US).
Indian Americans are the richest ethnicity in the US and the most likely ethnicity to be H1B holders or have arrived here through H1B work (Father's employment etc.)
If there were tons of qualified Americans who were being suppressed by H1Bs, then this demographic wouldn't be so wealthy.
At the same time, real wages for tech workers in the US have risen substantially and outpaced inflation substantially. Again if we were in a scenario where there was lots of available, qualified labor, this wouldn't happen. It especially wouldn't happen if the point of H1B hiring by tech companies was to suppress tech worker wages.
Now all those things together are puzzling: the income H1Bs earn, the rising real wages of the fields where H1Bs are employed. These don't make sense if there is a large pool of qualified applicants no company will hire.
Those data points all make sense if there isn't actually a large domestic pool of qualified talent. Then suddenly everything lines up really well. Bc H1bs are artificially limited, the talent pool would be artificially limited as well, which would drive up wages, much like we are seeing.
In your experience, are companies still doing H1Bs? Is it perceived as too risky to attempt now, or are people trying to rush H1Bs while the fees are "low"?
Gasp.
The fiction that there are tons of qualified Americans who are boxed out of tech is persistent but doesn't make any sense when you look at how high tech salaries are and how much real wages in the field have grown in the US. It would make no sense for that to happen if the labor pool for that field was large enough to absorb all the demand
I'm seeing a lot of news of people with legal status and no criminal records being arrested and detained (ranging from citizens, to people with pending AOS, to people who entered legally and have bona fide asylum cases) and wondering if there is likely to be any change in the near future.
Consider using your platform to help Eva Yi Xie, a Princeton neuroscience PhD student recently detained by ICE.
> According to Ms. Xie’s lawyers, because her asylum application has not yet been approved and her previous visa is expired, ICE agents were alerted when she passed through an airport security checkpoint.
— https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/20/science/chinese-scientist...
MAYBE relevant information other readers might want to know.
Remind me which countries allow you stay when visa expires?
I know a case where a person has waited for 4 years. I haven't heard of longer cases. So I'd assume 3-4 years.
Depending on the nationality, there might be some relevant local chats with more information, statistics, U.S. court cases, specialized attorneys...
Is the process frozen for everyone, or is this an exception? Is there anything he can do?
Thanks, and have a great rest of your day!
Quick rundown: I have a MS CS from the University of Hawaii and a BSC from ETH Zurich, Switzerland. I've been in the US on E-2 since 2022 but E-2 renewal doesn't look too good. No patents, awards or press coverage, no publications in the last 10y. No independent letter of recommendations.
Maybe a side question too, how much can I rely on Claude-as-a-lawyer and process guide? Has anyone been successful with that lately?
- Upton Sinclair
How is that relevant or useful information? You know full well that the H1Bs aren’t starting tech companies.
However, "Do you ever feel remorse for what you are doing" crosses into personal attack, and that is not allowed in this thread or any other on HN. We all have plenty to feel remorse about.
If you have a substantive point, you can make it respectfully and thoughtfully; if not, there's no need to post.
More here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50579469