Microsoft's SideWinder Strategic Commander was a failed attempt

(rockpapershotgun.com)

21 points | by Tomte 3 days ago

4 comments

  • aetherspawn 4 hours ago
    I don't know that RTS is the right genre for this kind of mouse, but for example Mechwarrior-like or MMORPG, where you really do have half a dozen different weapon/skill binds and need to fire them off quickly, this kind of layout makes more sense.

    In fact this mouse would absolutely destroy in Mechwarrior online because you could bind the different weapon groups on rotating and non-rotating parts, and left and right side of the mech separately, easily firing them around corners and stuff like that.

    • chuckadams 1 hour ago
      It's not a mouse. You're expected to have the mouse in your right hand, while the top of the Commander shifts around like a joystick. The twist-style joysticks turned out to be the killer hardware for Mechwarrior, but I could totally see using this alongside such a stick.

      I rather miss that era of gaming ... at least the crazy innovation. Getting 3d card drivers to behave, not so much.

    • 2muchcoffeeman 4 hours ago
      The correct controls for Mechwarrior is a joystick and throttle
  • rl3 3 days ago
    Still have mine. While I found it to be largely a detriment in games, it sure was fun to toy with and try stuff out.

    Such a cool peripheral even to this day, and completely magic around its release.

  • somat 3 days ago
    The strategic commander always felt like it should have been more successful. On paper it is the perfect the missing half for the native PC FPS controller.

    So, the mouse, If you had asked anyone to design a bespoke FPS controller, they would not design a mouse, yet somehow, this thing built to do something totally different, point at things on the screen, has proven to be the best fps controller, nobody has come up with anything better. Probably something about it's huge(for controller sizes) swing distance and absolute positioning.

    The problem is the other half, the keyboard, on the one hand it is sort of nice to have 100+ buttons to use, but you almost never need that many and it stinks to only have binary(on/off) movement.

    I have seen half controllers designed to solve this, but they never have enough buttons and are hard to hold, but the strategic commander, that makes one think, forget what it was built for, the RTS, it looks awkward as hell for that, but it does look perfect for the FPS.

    • orbital-decay 5 hours ago
      Biomechanically and due to how the nervous system works, the fastest and most precise movements can only be done with full arm movement and fingers for extra accuracy, on a device which is the most reactive (e.g. zero weight/static friction/hysteresis/dead zones) and has a very specific movement resistance (e.g. dynamic friction), low enough but not too low. Many control schemes have been tried over decades but these basic rules seem to give the best results. Which only leaves the scheme most skilled FPS players already prefer: a basic, most lightweight mouse with a properly centered sensor, held with something close to a claw grip, without too many buttons that would mess up your aiming. Plus a keyboard under the other hand, it's a lot less important than the mouse.

      Casual FPS play is more forgiving, e.g. gyro seems to work for many people as well (full arm + precise movement again, but not ideally reactive/resistant). But you can't put too many buttons on such a controller either.

    • 2muchcoffeeman 4 hours ago
      Incorrect. The Wii Mote was the best FPS controller. I could head shot with that all day long. Yes, it needed a level of refinement. But it was so natural.

      On the Switch, some FPS allow motion controls for fine aiming and the thumbstick for gross movements. A far more natural system than any other console.

  • MomsAVoxell 4 hours ago
    I once wrote an entire book about the Logitech Cyberman joystick/mouse combination and what could be done with it - I was contacted by O'Reilly themselves, because I had one, they'd seen my writing previously, and were convinced that this was going to be the hot new thing for controllers/peripherals, setting a new standard for PC devices ..

    https://www.computinghistory.org.uk/det/12416/logitech-cyber...

    It seemed like a good idea at the time, but it flopped.

    And it was during the course of this project that I discovered why: it was painful to use for longer than 10 or 15 minutes.

    So many of these projects start out as a kind of sci-fi fever dream, an ideation of the kinds of control surfaces one would find in space, zooming around asteroids, and .. that is inspiring and beautiful to all of us nerds, I would wager .. except it doesn't take into account the one very, very important element in all control surfaces, which overrides the aesthetic sensibilities and BOM desires of designers and accountants alike: gravity.

    Sure, the Cyberman would be awesome in a low-/no-gravity environment, and I'd use it all day/night/epoch as appropriate for getting the cargo docked and transferred to other star systems, mmmkay... but here on Earth the thing is a positive drag and what should've been a few days of serious computing and pixel shredding turns into a forearm torture par excellence.

    This is why the very boring, plain old mouse and keyboard have persisted, imho, because they harvest the one bit of energy that is accessible and inescapable on every single desk, for every single type of user in existence: gravity. That flat plane is inescapable. Devices which force you to resist it, even at the digit level, are going to be asking their users to simply do too much work, and the thing will eventually end up in its final destination: the back of some dusty drawer, somewhere ...