17 comments

  • abbadadda 5 hours ago
    “Gets stuck climbing” is an extremely poor choice of words here. When I hear “stuck” in the context of airplanes I think malfunction, like Boeing’s 737 MAX MCAS getting “stuck” trimming the aircraft’s nose downward.
    • JumpCrisscross 1 hour ago
      > “Gets stuck climbing” is an extremely poor choice of words here

      It's familiar if you've ever flown a plane. You can't climb–you're at max power (or max power for your fuel budget) and pointing the nose up doesn't only works for a bit, and risks stalling, versus waiting for your tanks to lighten. You're "stuck" at that altitude. It's reminiscent of driving uphill in a car with an underpowered engine (relative to what you're used to)–you get "stuck" at a speed.

  • havaloc 1 day ago
    As others have said, step climb is nothing new. To my eyes it seems to have a similar profile to the Boeing 767 where it starts out pretty "low" at say 32,000 or 34,000.

    I run the oldest turbulence forecasting website on the internet. What I don't like about narrow-body aircraft on transatlantic flights is that you have all these big jets that can go up to 37,000-40,000 right away and fly over turbulence. If you're on on a A321XLR, not only is it a small plane, but you're "stuck" at 32,000 or 34,000 bouncing around where you could overfly turbulence if you were in something bigger and more performant.

    • nickf 7 hours ago
      Perhaps an odd question, but do you know how the 752’s fared in the same TATL crossings? I used to do a lot of UA’s flights on that metal across the pond, and remember it being bumpier than my now-regular widebodies. Rumours swirl that the 321xlr might bring back my preferred route, but if it’s turbulent especially in winter, I might stick to routes out of LHR!
      • havaloc 2 hours ago
        It's been a while since I've tracked a 752 ( Boeing 757-200 for the pedants ) across the Atlantic, certainly not as common, and especially now, not like it used to be.

        Winter is the bumpiest time for transatlantic by far, so I'd probably stick to, in order, A380/A350, B787, A330, B777. I'll often see an A350 go right up to 39K+ ( feet ) and that helps a lot.

        I'd also say something else here, airline matters a lot. I've tracked thousands of flights over the 21 years that the site has been operating. It's my experience that some airlines will choose better routes than others by an astonishing degree.

        You would think it would be pretty standard and the flights take the Atlantic tracks no matter what, but that is not been my experience.

        • Zeetah 1 hour ago
          Can you please share your sorted list of better to not as good airlines from a route perspective?
          • havaloc 54 minutes ago
            This is something I've been leery to post for various reasons.

            Next time there's a heavy turbulence advisory over the Atlantic, watch eastbound flights (as they fly with the jet stream), and watch what the airlines do in terms of route (some go off the tracks), or altitude (fly under/over, sometimes at ~28,000ft), to make the flight more comfortable.

            I've been doing it for years and I still can't believe the variance.

            If you really want to know, reach out to me.

      • devman0 3 hours ago
        The 757 has really good climb performance for a mainline commercial jet not sure if it would have the same issues as the XLR
        • havaloc 2 hours ago
          I can't remember the details other than it was a US domestic flight, but I tracked a 757 at 42,000 feet once.
    • adonskoi12 5 hours ago
      Same a380, start with 35 and by the end of 15hours flight we were at 39
    • a3w 4 hours ago
      havaloc 19 hours ago | prev | next [–]

      > it starts out pretty "low" at say 32,000 or 34,000.

      No unit given. Asuming micro-Hitlers. Wasn't there an XKCD about that?

  • aschla 1 day ago
    "It must be trapped at low altitudes for the first few hours of a trip..."

    The lack of detail here makes it sound like it's flying at 10k feet...

    "...early cruising levels will be severely restricted when the aircraft lifts off beyond 85% MTOW, frequently topping out at just 32,000 feet (9,700 meters)."

    ...yet 32k is a fairly normal cruising altitude.

    Step climbing is a normal procedure for any long haul flight. It's not unique to the A321XLR. It's just at the bad end of the spectrum because it's a smaller aircraft, with a higher, less efficient wing load, compared to the usual long haulers like the 777 and 787. The 777-300ER is very similar in wing load and would perform relatively similarly to the A321XLR.

    • porphyra 1 day ago
      Using words like "trapped" and "restricted" are unnecessarily negative imo. Actually in the fifth paragraph the article finally explains why: In order to carry more fuel for its long range, it's too heavy and its wings won't have enough lift in the thinner air at high altitudes. So it climbs up only after burning some fuel so it's lighter. And this is a pretty common design for long haulers like you mentioned.
      • left-struck 12 hours ago
        This article is written in a cynical way to game something,I suspect. Maybe SEO? As mentioned above it uses hysterical over exaggeration, but what annoyed me the most was it keeps repeating itself. As you read further you do get more detailed information, but it repeats what you read earlier and adds more. So annoying.
        • mahkeiro 11 hours ago
          Totally agree. The article is awfully written and keeps repeating itself. It's likely LLM-assisted just to hit a certain length.
          • g-b-r 3 hours ago
            For what it might count, as someone with no aviation knowledge I found it interesting, engaging and not LLM-sounding, although the title seems to make little sense
        • margalabargala 12 hours ago
          It absolutely is.

          It climbs at a "taxing" 500 feet per minute? Why would I care how quickly my aircraft climbed?

    • dotancohen 6 hours ago
      I understand that redesigning the wings isn't that far off from having to certify a new airframe design. That said, extending the wings a few metres would have the benefits of both more lift and more fuel capacity - possibly negating the need for the heavy CFTs on this aircraft.

      Didn't Boeing do something similar? Was it the 747-8 that got longer wings? Or maybe a 777 variant?

    • mopsi 13 hours ago

        > Step climbing is a normal procedure for any long haul flight. 
      
      There was an interesting incident in the 1980s when Soviet air force shot down a South Korean airliner that had flown over the Sakhalin island in the Pacific due to accumulating navigation error on its way from the US to South Korea. At some point when a fighter jet was trailing it, the airliner began to climb for fuel economy, and the fighter interpreted it as an escape attempt, which contributed to misidentification as a spy plane.

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_Air_Lines_Flight_007

    • rwmj 1 day ago
      I have a memory that in the 1980s all jet airliners cruised at 30,000 ft (except Concorde), and it is only more recently that they have cruised higher (at ~ 38,000). Is that true or am I misremembering?
      • dingaling 23 hours ago
        Boeing long-haulers have been certificated to at least 43,000ft since the 747.

        Airbus traditionally certificated to 41,000ft but increased to 43,000 with the A350 and A380.

        Big biz jets cruise happily at 50,000ft plus, they're limited more by maximum rate of descent in case of emergency rather than aerodynamics.

        • Melatonic 12 hours ago
          Do the biz jets just have the advantage of less weight to lift ratio ? Or are they benefiting more from modern engines ?
          • exidy 10 hours ago
            It's a complex topic but a very brief summary would be that the smaller difference between full and empty weights, less constraints on physical size and not having to chase the last % of cost-per-passenger mile basically means a bizjet can run with a less wing loading and therefore cruise higher.
          • huiguo856 6 hours ago
            > Do the biz jets just have the advantage of less weight to lift ratio ? Or are they benefiting more from modern engines ?

            Basically: Biz jets are smaller

            • dotancohen 6 hours ago
              In aviation in particular, and transportation in general, rarely is that an efficiency advantage.
          • TylerE 9 hours ago
            "weight to lift" isn't a thing. In level flight, forces balance. Weight = lift.
            • filleduchaos 6 hours ago
              It absolutely is a thing seeing as aircraft don't teleport around in level flight, and is directly relevant to why airliners tend to have lower service ceilings than bizjets.

              The relationship between thrust, load factor, wing loading and the coffin corner is more complex than just "weight = lift"

        • t0mas88 9 hours ago
          [dead]
      • TylerE 1 day ago
        Somewhat. Even the (almost) oldest of old school 707 could cruise at 38,000-42,000ft depending on subvariant.

        However, with newer high bypass engines the efficiency gains of flying real high are greater, and with their greater climb performance they can get up there on shorter flights.

        • paulryanrogers 1 day ago
          Why is flying higher more efficient? Don't the engines need to pull in more air since it's thinner? Or does the reduced air friction make for a net win?
          • TylerE 1 day ago
            Reduced friction is a bigger win.

            Edit: But it's a balancing act. Fly TOO high, and you'll have to fly with too much angle of attack (nose up angle, essentially) to maintain altitude and that puts you back in the bad part of the drag curve. This is where the whole step climb behavior TFA details comes from. As the plane gets lighter the most efficient altitude goes up.

          • ExoticPearTree 8 hours ago
            The reduced drag at higher altitudes reduces fuel consumption and more than compensates the fuel burn to get there. The engines don’t need to “pull in more air” at higher altitudes.

            This is the reason airplanes, commercial ones in particular, retract the landing gear as soon as possible. The drag added by the landing gear is quite significant.

      • prmph 1 day ago
        Yes, even in 2006, on a trip to South Africa, I remember our 747 was cruising at around 30,000 feet
      • ajross 1 day ago
        No, the way the physics works is that the distance/energy efficiency varies (to first order anyway) with the air temperature. And it's colder the higher you get, up to this funny layer called the tropopause where the temperature (somewhat oddly) stops varying with altitude at all. And this altitude varies a little, but is always right around 36kft.

        So as soon as jets were powerful enough to get there, they all wanted to fly at the tropopause, but no higher.

        • sho 1 day ago
          Your ideas about the tropopause are a bit eccentric. 36kft is just a model average, it's more like 25kft at the poles and 50-60kft at the equator. Large jetliners fly well below and above it all the time.

          Temperature's just one factor. Air density, lift-to-drag ratio, weight, speed and engine performance all matter. Thinner air reduces drag, but you still need to generate enough lift, and there's a point beyond which the trade-off stops paying off. Business jets are generally lighter, with wings and engines designed for higher-altitude cruising, and regularly fly above 40kft, sometimes even 50kft.

          The general max service height of airliners is an engineering trade-off between air density, lift-to-drag, weight, speed and engine efficiency. Air temp is part of it, but a small part, and there's nothing magical about the tropopause.

          • ajross 23 hours ago
            Shrug, this is the middle of the bell curve argument. The Jedi and I are off at the ends repeating "Jets fly at the FL360 tropopause and have since they were invented".

            Though I'll allow myself one bit of pedantry:

            > Business jets are generally lighter, with wings and engines designed for higher-altitude cruising, and regularly fly above 40kft, sometimes even 50kft.

            This is wrong. Bizjets fly high because their passengers like it and because they can get places faster. They fly more efficiently at the tropopause for the same reason jetliners do. There's no design difference other than flying "more empty" with more available thrust.

    • contemporary343 1 day ago
      Yes, this is nothing that unusual or likely noticeable at all. It won’t rocket up like a 757, but it’s way more efficient and has much lower emissions per passenger.
      • havaloc 1 day ago
        There will never be another aircraft like the 757: https://askthepilot.com/ode-to-the-757/
        • dotancohen 6 hours ago
          Airliners are not unlike taxicabs owned by a large corp and driven by hired drivers. The people who matter in this regard are the pax and the owners - the drivers' comfort is a small factor so long as he is reasonably not uncomfortable.

          The powerful 757 is great. Lower takeoff and landing speeds and higher rate of climb are comfortable for the pilot. But they consume more fuel (money) for the owners and the pax don't care.

          I think I've seen less than a dozen 57s in the air this past decade. They're gorgeous - even just aestheticly I'd love to see more. But they are less cost efficient, and the decision makers don't like that.

          For the same reason, we don't see Bentley taxicabs.

          • devilbunny 2 hours ago
            Eight years ago Delta was still running them. Flew a 757 from Atlanta to Stuttgart and back. Maybe not now.
            • dotancohen 1 hour ago
              In not in the US, maybe that's why I rarely see them. Thanks for letting me know they still fly regularly!
            • havaloc 2 hours ago
              Delta still has 88 of them predominantly the 200 variant, according to Wikipedia.

              They're hard to get rid of because they're so good at what they do, fuel economy and age aside.

    • ErroneousBosh 4 hours ago
      > ...yet 32k is a fairly normal cruising altitude.

      <looks on flightradar24>

      Yeah that's about what everyone overflying me is doing, except for the wee Grobs from the RAF base a dozen or so miles away pottering about at 2000-3000 or thereabouts.

    • maxcan 1 day ago
      Exactly. I only fly much smaller single engine planes (TBM 900). We could easily fly to our max altitude of FL310 even at max gross takeoff weight but the odds of ATC granting us an unrestricted climb was near zero.

      This article is a pretty big nothing burger.

      • netsharc 23 hours ago
        Typical terribly written content farm slop. (Some of the short sentences make me suspicious about AI slop, but nothing jumped out at me to indicate it). It's repetitive and as thin on information as the air is at 38000ft.

        I did learn that if you're heavy and you try to cruise at much thinner air, it means a higher angle of attack which means more drag. It made me realize that airliner forward movement is a combination of jet thrust and gliding. And that like paper airliners, even airliners has a glide component.

        Also I hated the moronic term "delete" in the sentence

        > Depending on the mission, airlines could install or delete optional auxiliary center tanks in the belly hold

        • dotancohen 6 hours ago
          Delete actually is the industry term used for uninstalled optional equipment.
  • growse 1 day ago
    Reminds me of the original Airbus (Concorde) for which "top of climb" and "top of descent" were the same thing.
  • YJ57-P-3 1 day ago
    This is profoundly not a new thing. Aircraft with high ceilings and high gross weights normally have to do some form of step climb if they're taking off near max takeoff weight.

    B-52Ds with the 'big belly' modification and external stores flying missions from Guam to Viet Nam in the 1960s/70s would struggle to 20,000 ft or so, then would slowly climb to more normal cruise altitudes as they burned fuel until they had lost enough weight that they could maintain best economy cruise (a variable, but usually something like .85 Mach above 30,000) ft.

  • dev_l1x_be 1 day ago
    Not sure but:

    This site can’t be reached The web page at https://simpleflying.com/airbus-a321xlr-often-stuck-climbing... might be temporarily down or it may have moved permanently to a new web address. ERR_HTTP2_PROTOCOL_ERROR

  • gwbas1c 1 day ago
    The picture at "The Heavy Cost Of Extreme Range In A Narrowbody" is comical. There's no way planes can safely fly that closely together.

    What I'd like to know is how they made that image: What's real, what's photoshop, and what's prompted?

    • canarypilot 1 day ago
      From the livery and a little memory, this looks like a grab from Airbus’ 2019 50th anniversary celebratory formation flight.

      There’s a video on YouTube and it predates AIPocalypse so fairly trustworthy. I couldn’t quite pick out the exact moment in the video footage so may have been a still captured in the same shoot.

      Regardless, something very close to this was done in the real world.

    • burmanm 1 day ago
      They're not actually as close as it appears in the image. This is just a clever "trick" with proper telescope lens, merging things closer.
      • dylan604 1 day ago
        They're way closer than they ever would be during normal operations. This is clearly done with plans and clearance for formation flying. You're trying to hand wave it off as nothing special done, yet they clearly made all sorts of specific plans to fly this closely. Sure, they're not as close as the Blue Angels can fly, but they are way closer than anyone would ever expect to see in normal situations
    • vachina 1 day ago
      It's called perspective compression. Happens when you take a photo with a very long focal length (zoom)
      • pocksuppet 23 hours ago
        > very long focal length (zoom)

        That's not what focal length is. Focal length basically controls the amount of perspective. It also changes the size of things, but not in the same way zoom does. Changing the zoom and focal length in opposing ways generates a famous movie effect called the "dolly zoom" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolly_zoom (with visual example)

        • hencq 22 hours ago
          This is either weirdly pedantic or just wrong. Zooming is changing the focal length. A dolly zoom changes the focal length while also moving the camera itself.
    • ceejayoz 1 day ago
      > There's no way planes can safely fly that closely together.

      Never been to an airshow?

      Here's how they take that sort of photo, from the official Airbus account: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JS6w-DXiZpk

      • dylan604 1 day ago
        That's much less "how" than just a demo. A "how" video would have footage from the plane taking the group shots
        • ceejayoz 1 day ago
          The "how" is "they fly close together in a way they wouldn't normally for the photo".
  • retube 22 hours ago
    > hiking fuel consumption by an estimated 2.5%

    I'd happily pay an extra 10%, 20%, 100% for a really nice wide operational envelope

  • funkytownjoe 1 hour ago
    Too much dei
  • ixtli 1 day ago
    This article was very interesting but restated the same thing over and over and over again. Could have been two or three paragraphs. Why do people do this?
    • pfdietz 1 day ago
      > Why do people do this?

      The answer is usually "incentives".

    • rrr_oh_man 1 day ago
      That's typical LLM writing.

      Humans, in professional non-fiction writing, more often either write pyramid-shaped texts (-> journalism) or use progressive depth (starting with the general idea, exploring deeper points as we go).

    • izacus 1 day ago
      Because it was AI generated and it's clickbait nonsense.
    • brookst 1 day ago
      Yeah o actually kept reading out of morbid curiosity to see just how many times they could say rephrase rhe same three points.
    • BlackRabbit1 1 day ago
      Wrong LLM prompt?
    • kylehotchkiss 1 day ago
      low quality avgeek website that probably profits from credit card referrals. It's an entire ecosystem :D
    • inexcf 1 day ago
      [flagged]
  • bayindirh 58 minutes ago
    The overall tone of the article is depressing. Like it's doing something by force or something not designed to do.

    It's a plane designed to do something normally narrowbody planes don't do: cross an ocean, and needs engineering trade-offs.

    I for one, believe the choices, trade-offs and the resulting achievement is clever, and worth celebrating. Not stuffing negative words to sound like it's something bad.

    Also, it smells like the whole article is written with AI and not cleaned up. Reads badly, feels off. IDK, the article's flight is more burdensome than 321XLR's for me.

  • bestouff 1 day ago
    This article has a suspiciouly very negative tone. This is not your independant technical analysis, there's politics in there.
    • ceejayoz 1 day ago
      If you read to the end, it's fairly positive.
      • smallerfish 1 day ago
        Disagree. It's hard to read this article and come away with the impression that this is a fuel efficient aircraft.
        • ceejayoz 1 day ago
          But that's not the point of the aircraft.

          It is more fuel-efficient than a half-empty widebody on a small but long route.

          https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_A321neo#A321XLR

          > In October 2018, the A321XLR was proposed to Air Transat and AerCap: Air Transat could reach Southern European destinations such as Split, Croatia from Montreal and Toronto.

        • fransje26 23 hours ago
          Because that was exactly the goal of the article.

          On the contrary, spending a little more time to read the comments at the bottom of the article and in this HN thread would have brought you the knowledge that it is perfectly normal/common to start cruising at FL320 and move stepwise up as the plane gets lighter.

  • tomaytotomato 1 day ago
    I love aircraft and planes, but as I get older and read more about the technical and environmental phenomenon that have to be balanced in the dance of "aerospace engineering", the more I wish I was just ignorant to all the variety of things that can go wrong.
    • left-struck 7 hours ago
      Reminds me of that saying, idk exactly how it goes but something like software security experts usually recommend having a physical lock and physical security experts recommend having an software lock.
    • jakzurr 13 hours ago
      Same. One of the reasons I don't like to fly any more. (Well, except I'd go up with a private pilot in a heartbeat. What, ya wanta live forever?)
  • kylehotchkiss 1 day ago
    No way I'd ever cross an ocean in a narrowbody plane. Widebodies have room to actually stand near the bathrooms for a few minutes and stretch your legs.
    • solids 1 day ago
      The problem is that this is already decided for us. It will just take time.
      • brookst 1 day ago
        It’s decided for us, by us. People are so price sensitive on airline tickets that they’ll take any tradeoff the lowest price entails.

        Same reason modern economy class is trending to 28 inch seat pitch, and maybe lower.

        • kalleboo 12 hours ago
          I thought the transition to narrowbodies wasn't due to price but due to the transition from hub-and-spoke to point-to-point as people prefer direct flights?
        • expedition32 6 hours ago
          That's nothing new. You remember the 747 because of its cocktail bar- the reality of the 747 was flying 400 tourists to Ibiza or Okinawa.

          All the airliners lost money before the age of mass tourism.

        • markdown 14 hours ago
          • jakzurr 13 hours ago
            For some reason, I thought those seats just looked comfy. Oh well, I'll probably never be able to try one.
            • abenga 8 hours ago
              Because they are reasonably spaced here. Fully realized and after a decade or so of optimization, it is yet another step towards packing us in like Pringles.
      • d_silin 1 day ago
        Only for some very niche routes, like Reykjavík-Halifax.

        Transatlantic is the busiest air corridor and there are only so many slots in the air and airports. Bigger airliners allow more passengers in a single flight = more revenue.

        • neilo40 1 day ago
          Glasgow - Halifax was served by 737 when I did it a few years ago. Felt a little weird initially but it turned out fine
          • sq_ 1 day ago
            Similarly, a family member recently did LAX to DUB on an Aer Lingus A320 (or maybe A321). Seems like the airlines are responding to folks hating connections?
            • aceofspades19 11 hours ago
              Are you sure it wasn't an A330? Aer Lingus operates the A330 on the LAX to DUB route. It would be too far even on an A321 XLR.
    • happosai 1 day ago
      Perhaps you won't, but a large enough percentage of customers will find it an acceptable trade-off for a slightly cheaper flight ticket. Especially if a narrow body flight is direct and the widebody involves a connection at a busy hub.
    • kube-system 1 day ago
      I find transatlantic on a 321xlr to be tolerable if its a daytime flight and has decent meal service.

      But I'll never do a red eye transatlantic on a 321xlr again.

    • insom 1 day ago
      I flew Montreal to Dublin on an A321neo and it was my worst aviation experience by far. And I’ve been diverted after a lightning strike.
  • avazhi 11 hours ago
    >To overcome the weight of its massive fuel load, the A321XLR must perform a calculated, multi-hour sequence with air traffic control known as step climbing. The flight crew must climb to a lower, temporary altitude, level off, and wait.

    What an atrocious article. Every airliner flight longer than a few hours or so uses step climbs. Wtf is this slop?

  • izacus 1 day ago
    "Stuck at FL320" which is... a rather normal FL.

    Get outta here with this clickbait nonsense.

    • allenrb 1 day ago
      Seriously. I was imagining well under 20kft from the tone of the headline. But I guess the need to climb from FL320 to FL380 in 2kft increments fails to grab the eyeballs.

      Sigh.

  • sdoering 1 day ago
    While this is a real operating constraint I am missing evidence of a major airline problem. The article turns normal flight planning into something much more dramatic.

    Step climbing is routine on long-haul aircraft, including widebodies. A fuel-heavy aircraft initially cruises lower, then climbs as it gets lighter. It isn’t continuously struggling uphill for hours. Lower than the eventual cruise altitude does not necessarily mean below the optimum altitude as the optimum changes with weight if my understanding is correct. And yes, the article acknowledges this, but then (imho misleadingly) treats those initial lower levels as an automatic efficiency penalty.

    Also, yes, the XLR’s extra weight does involve trade-offs. But airlines evaluate fuel consumption over the whole mission, not how quickly an aircraft reaches 37,000 feet.

    The article does not establish that carriers are experiencing this systematically. Its “2.5% per hour” fuel penalty has no clear calculation or baseline, and the claim that climbing above 32,000 feet leaves only “a few knots” of safe margin is presented without supporting performance data.

    The “coffin corner” framing is particularly sensational.